What is a Profit 4 Good Business?

At its core, the Profit 4 Good movement is about a simple, powerful choice: deciding that the purpose of a business should be to make the world a better place, not to enrich private shareholders.

A Profit 4 Good business is one that dedicates 100% of its net profit to charitable causes.

Profit 4 Good businesses exist because the people behind them want to leave the world better than they found it. By structurally locking 100% of net profits to charitable purposes, these companies become sustainable, permanent engines for funding progress.

Instead of relying solely on one-off donations, a Profit 4 Good business embeds systemic giving into the global economy. Every day the business operates, it is actively empowering communities, protecting environments, and building a fairer society.

Global Business Structures: How it Works

To donate 100% of their net profits to charity as efficiently as possible, Profit 4 Good businesses must tailor their structure to the corporate and tax laws of their home country. Here’s how the primary models work across different regions:

1. Australia, New Zealand, & The United Kingdom

Ease of Use: Very High. Highly supportive and straightforward frameworks.

  • 100% Charity Ownership Allowed? Yes. Charities can freely own 100% of a commercial trading company.
  • Tax Exemptions for Charity-Owned Companies: 100% Tax-Exempt. In the UK and NZ, profits pass to charities completely tax-free via Gift Aid or trust exemptions. In Australia, the charity claims a cash refund for corporate taxes paid (via franking credits), reaching a 100% tax-free result.
  • The 100% Profit-Donation Model (Independent Businesses): Very Tax-Efficient. Independent companies can donate up to 100% of their net profits directly to charities to offset their corporate tax bill to £0/$0.
  • Direct Charity Operations: Charities can directly sell goods and services to the public tax-free, provided the trading directly advances their core charitable purpose (e.g., an educational charity selling books or paid training courses).
2. Canada

Ease of Use: Moderate. Requires strict corporate separation to maximize tax deductions.

  • 100% Charity Ownership Allowed? Yes, but must be arms-length. Charities can hold 100% of a separate company's shares as long as they don't run day-to-day operations.
  • Tax Exemptions for Charity-Owned Companies: 75% Tax-Exempt. A charity-owned company can donate its profits directly to its parent charity as a deductible expense - sheltering up to 75% of its net income from corporate tax.
  • The 100% Profit-Donation Model (Independent Businesses): 75% Tax-Exempt. Independent businesses can only deduct charitable donations up to 75% of net income per year. Donating 100% of profits still leaves 25% subject to standard corporate tax.
  • Direct Charity Operations: Canadian charities can sell goods and services directly to the public under their own charitable name. However, that commercial revenue is only tax-exempt if the activity is a "Related Business" (directly tied to their charitable mission, like a Salvation Army op shop or a charity café employing at-risk youth) or run 90%+ by unpaid volunteers. Selling unrelated commercial goods/services using paid staff directly inside the charity is strictly banned by the CRA and risks their charitable status.
3. United States

Ease of Use: Complex. Flexible corporate options, but strict corporate donation caps can result in personal tax workarounds or alternative ownership structures (Pass-Throughs or Purpose Trusts).

  • 100% Charity Ownership Allowed? Yes. US Public Charities can legally own 100% of a commercial C-Corporation.
    Note: Private Foundations are restricted by the "Excess Business Holdings" rule (IRC §4943), which limits their ownership of a commercial business to 20%.
  • Tax Exemptions for Charity-Owned Companies: No exemption at the operating business level. The commercial company pays standard 21% federal corporate tax on its net income. However, once corporate tax is paid, the remaining post-tax income is sent to the parent charity as a 100% tax-free dividend.
  • The 100% Profit-Donation Model (Independent Businesses): Strictly Capped (10%). US C-Corporations can only deduct charitable donations up to 10% of taxable income per year. Donating 100% of profit still leaves 90% subject to standard corporate tax.
  • The Pass-Through Workaround: To bypass the 10% corporate cap, American founders often structure as a Pass-Through LLC or S-Corporation. The profit passes through to the founder's personal tax return, allowing them to donate directly using individual donor limits - sheltering up to 50%–60% of their Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) in year one, carrying over any remaining deductions over 5 years.
  • The Purpose Trust & 501(c)(4) Model (The Patagonia Route): To bypass the 10% deduction cap and the strict ownership/political restrictions placed on standard 501(c)(3) charities, founders can split voting and economic ownership:
    • Voting Control: Placed into a Purpose Trust to permanently lock in the company’s social mission and corporate governance without losing control to outside shareholders.
    • Profit Rights: Non-voting economic stock (e.g., 98%) is donated to a 501(c)(4) Social Welfare Organization.
    • Tax & Reality: The operating company pays standard 21% US corporate tax on earnings. The remaining post-tax profits flow to the 501(c)(4) as tax-free dividends, which can then be spent on environmental activism, lobbying, and advocacy. While the founder gets no personal income tax deduction for donating the shares, they legally eliminate capital gains and estate tax liabilities while dedicating 100% of ongoing dividend distributions to public benefit.
  • Direct Charity Operations: US charities can sell goods and services directly. How that revenue is treated depends on whether the activity is "related" or "unrelated" to their exempt mission:
    • Related Trading (Tax-Exempt): Income generated directly from fulfilling the charity's mission (e.g., a non-profit hospital charging for care, or a non-profit theater selling show tickets).
    • Unrelated Trading (Taxed - UBIT): Commercial activity that generates revenue but does not directly advance the primary mission (e.g., an environmental charity running a commercial parking lot). Income is subject to Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT). If unrelated commercial trading becomes too substantial, the IRS can revoke the charity's tax-exempt status altogether.

Aligning Commerce with Compassion

People naturally want to do the right thing. When customers realize that a business isn't pocketing the cash, but is instead directing 100% of its net margins to real-world solutions, a powerful shift happens.

A Clear Choice

Given the option, people overwhelmingly prefer to buy from a business that aligns with their values rather than one that enriches anonymous investors.

The Ethical Premium

Customers are often entirely willing to participate in this model - even paying a bit more if needed - because they know their purchase serves a deeper purpose. It transforms a standard transaction into a collective act of goodwill.

The Charitable Ownership Advantage

Because the core motivation is purely philanthropic, something remarkable happens to the business itself. This is known as the Charitable Ownership Advantage (COA) thesis, which makes a testable claim: The exact same business is worth more and generates higher margins under charitable ownership than under private ownership.

Unlike other ethical frameworks (such as Fair Trade or organic sourcing) that alter the operations layer and introduce higher input costs, a Profit 4 Good business operates at the ownership layer. The products, pricing, and operational efficiencies stay competitive.

However, because stakeholders - customers, employees, and suppliers - naturally prefer to support a business that gives back, the company gains a series of subtle, organic advantages:

  • Stronger Customer Loyalty: Lower acquisition costs and higher customer retention.
  • Inspired Teams: Employees find deep meaning in their daily labor, leading to higher engagement and drastically lower turnover.
  • Margin Leverage: On thin business margins, these modest advantages compound geometrically.

Ultimately, the COA model demonstrates a beautiful truth: by focusing entirely on making the world a better place, a business naturally becomes more resilient, allowing it to generate even more funding for the charities it supports.

Resources & Related Movements

Project COA (Charitable Ownership Advantage) ↗

Explore the Charitable Ownership Advantage thesis, which explores how structurally locking 100% of net profits to charitable purposes makes a business more resilient, profitable, and culturally impactful.

100% for Purpose ↗

A growing global movement and network of purpose-driven organizations committed to returning 100% of their profits to charitable initiatives and social good. The network is run by Newman's Own Foundation.

Giving What We Can ↗

A community of effective altruists. Through their "Company Pledge," businesses can officially pledge to donate a fixed percentage of their net profits (such as 10% or more) to highly effective organizations doing good in the world.

Explore the Directory